ABSTRACTS
Helga Druxes (Williams College)
A Nation of Bricoleurs in Amélie and Les Triplettes de Belleville
My
paper performs a feminist analysis of the role of the female protagonist
in the recent blockbuster comedy about life in Paris: Amélie
(Jean-Pierre Jeunet, 2001) and examines the representation of city spaces
to depict everyday life in France. Why are women assigned the repair work
to alleviate the tedium of everyday routines? Do they embrace this responsibility
or rebel against it? Which class markers and codes are endorsed in the
representation of ordinary people and urban locations, and on whose bodies
are they inscribed? What happens to the subaltern body of the beur
in this nostalgic fantasy of a social structure and nation? I argue that
Jeunet's film gives us a sanitized stereotype of French identity as "white"
and middle-class and that class tensions play a veiled but structurally
crucial role in the fantastically unitary petit bourgeois universe of
Amélie. Even though the main characters have working class occupations,
their lifestyles mimic the leisured middle class. The actual working class
is depicted as an underclass of childlike beurs who need to be disciplined
and held to a reductive standard of French culture.
The outright antagonism between the shopkeeper and his beur salesclerk
and deliveryman Lucien is repeated in an attenuated form in the friendship
between the reclusive retiree M. Dufayel and Lucien. M.Dufayel becomes
a parental figure both to Lucien and Amélie, but the advice he dispenses
is tinged with monocultural xenophobia. For instance, Lucien receives
painting lessons and turns out to be a far more talented portraitist of
urban working-class crowds than his teacher. But instead of receiving
praise for his use of bold color and his originality, his technique is
criticized and he is told to reproduce the kitschy model of Renoir's guinguette
scene, to which an elusive interiority is ascribed.
Amélie waitresses in a bistro frequented by a range of more or less eccentric
regulars. She moves between her place of work, her own apartment building,
her father's house in suburbia, the train station, a porn shop, a fun
fair, the Sacré Coeur, and many other quaint or eccentric destinations
in the city. In a plot that teeters on the edge of sappy nostalgia, Amélie
is on a maverick quest to restore treasured pieces of the lost past to
people in her orbit and finds true love into the bargain. Amélie performs
a surreal twisting of daily routines, thereby transforming them into exotic
events, perhaps even little fables that teach a moral. Home and the neighborhood
are the privileged places for these interventions. Despite the passage
of time, these locations are intact, memories and buried desires can be
reclaimed in most cases and a new social network of hyper- individuated
personages establishes itself around Amélie's stratagems. The film's optimistic
tone suggests that we just need to change our perspective on the everyday
to infuse it with pleasure and excitement. There is no realistic portrayal
of anomie and alienation in the urban workplace, nor are fragmentation,
acceleration and rendundancy confronted as inherent conditions of modern
living.
Using Bourdieu's notion of "habitus" to analyze the style politics of
the films and the notion of iconic Frenchness they promote, I will show
that this imaginary France of bricoleur individualist relies
on contrastive "propping" by an underclass, which performs essential routines.
I will end my presentation with a comparison between Amélie and
Les Triplettes de Belleville (Sylvian Chomet, 2003), a more recent
film which also depicts France as a nation of bricoleurs. However,
contrary to Jeunet, Chomet satirically exposes and deconstructs national
stereotypes the French and Americans hold about each other. |